Canary Testing Explained: What is a Canary Test and Why Use It?

Ensuring a smooth new release is critical to maintaining user satisfaction and operational stability. One proven technique for achieving this is canary testing, where a small subset of users is exposed to a new version of the software before rolling it out to the entire user base. Often referred to as a canary release or canary deployment, this method serves as an early warning system, much like the coal miners' practice of using canaries to detect danger.

TL;DR

• Canary testing involves exposing a small subset of users to a new software version to detect issues before a full rollout, minimizing risk.
• It allows real-world testing in production, with feedback guiding developers on potential bugs or performance issues.
• Benefits include minimizing disruptions, data-driven insights, and easy rollbacks in case of failures.
• Effective canary testing requires feature flags, monitoring key metrics, and careful planning to ensure accurate results and minimize risks.

Check also:

• Choose the Best Test Automation Tool: A Comprehensive Guide
• Best Selenium Practice Websites
• Why Should You Use data-testid Attributes?

What is Canary Testing?

Canary testing is a software testing technique where a small portion of users or systems are exposed to a new version or feature before it is rolled out to the entire user base. This method helps identify any issues or bugs in a controlled testing environment, minimizing the risk of widespread problems. If the canary version works well, the update is progressively released to the remaining users.

The term originates from the practice of using canaries in coal mines to detect dangerous gases; similarly, in software, the "canary" version serves as an early warning system.

How Does Canary Testing Work?

By performing a canary deployment, developers can test new functionality and features in a production environment without risking the stability of the entire system. The practice is similar to blue-green deployment, where a staged approach is used, but with canary testing, the focus is on deploying to a small group of users first. This method, often supported by a feature flag, helps to detect potential bugs or performance issues, enabling quick rollbacks if necessary.

Canary Test Deployment

The feedback from this small group of users provides valuable insights, allowing developers to analyze critical metrics before pushing the new software to the full user base. This technique is particularly effective in environments that utilize continuous delivery, ensuring new code is released frequently while minimizing risks. Ultimately, canary testing allows developers to deploy new features confidently, with real-time user feedback guiding the release process.

This approach represents one of the best practices for managing risk in software development while ensuring the smooth deployment of new functionality to an ever-growing number of users.

Benefits of Canary Testing

• Testing in a real production environment: Canary testing allows the development team to test new features in the actual production environment, which helps catch production bugs that might have been missed during internal testing.
• Isolating the canary group: By limiting the canary group to a small portion of users, canary testing reduces the impact of bugs while still validating new functionality before a full-scale release.
• Limiting disruptions: This sequential testing process minimizes potential disruptions compared to a full release, offering a clear advantage in terms of risk management.
• Data-driven insights: Running canary tests provides valuable metrics such as error rates and user engagement, allowing developers to make informed, data-driven decisions.
• Minimal disruption with rollback: If any issues are detected during the testing process, a rollback can be quickly performed, protecting the product's stability with minimal disruption.

Best Practices for Performing Canary Testing

To perform successful canary testing, follow these key practices:

1. Identify Your Canary Group: Choose a small number of users that represent a diverse subset of your overall audience. This ensures that the canary release covers different use cases and behaviors.
2. Run Canary Tests with Feature Flags: Using feature flags allows developers to toggle new features on or off for specific users. This is particularly useful when running canary tests, as it provides flexibility in controlling the software update for the canary group without requiring a full-scale rollback if something goes wrong.
3. Monitor Key Metrics: Keep a close eye on performance indicators such as error rates, response times, and user activity. The canary testing process should focus on gathering data from these metrics to assess the impact of the software release. Tools for automated testing can help with monitoring and alerting.
4. Prepare for Rollback: In case the canary group encounters significant issues, be ready to revert to the original version of the software. The saying "if the canary died, something is wrong" holds true—if the canary release exhibits critical errors, a quick rollback protects the rest of the user base.
5. Test in Two Identical Production Environments: Mirroring your production environment for testing can help ensure that results from the canary group are reliable. Running canary tests in such environments lets you identify problems more accurately.

Challenges of Canary Testing

• Identifying the right canary group: Determining the appropriate size and composition of the canary group can be difficult. The group needs to represent the larger user base to ensure accurate and reflective results.
• Bugs at scale: Although canary testing reduces risk, there is still a possibility that production bugs slip through, especially those that only manifest when tested at full scale.
• Actionable user feedback: Gathering meaningful and actionable feedback from the canary users can be challenging. The feedback may be subjective, and it can be tricky to balance the responses of a small group of users with the needs of the larger audience.

How Canary Testing Fits with Continuous Delivery

In continuous delivery, new software changes are constantly being integrated and deployed. Canary testing works well with this model because it allows developers to validate changes in a controlled manner before pushing them to the entire system. By implementing canary testing alongside a feature flag strategy, teams can introduce new features, test them, and gather feedback all while maintaining the stability of the broader platform.

Conclusion

To sum up, canary testing is a technique that allows developers to test and validate software changes in a real-world environment by gradually exposing them to a small group of users. While canary testing offers numerous benefits, including reducing risk and validating new software, it requires careful planning and monitoring. When running canary tests with feature flags, developers can further control the deployment and react swiftly if issues arise. Ultimately, canary testing offers an efficient way to improve the software release process, ensuring a smooth rollout for all users while minimizing potential disruptions.

Happy (automated) testing!